| |
Superintendent Survey
September, 2005
The School Board hired the California School Board Association (CSBA) for the search for a permanent Superintendent. The CSBA conducted interviews with Alameda stakeholders. The consultant used a form that contained open ended questions in three areas. Using that form I developed my own online survey.
90 inividuals took the survey with 51 Parents, 22 District Employees and 29 Community Members classifying themselves (multiple classifications allowed).
Below are the results from that survey.
Skills
Experience
Personal Traits
Skills
|
|
Important |
Very
Important |
Must Have |
Response
Average |
Curriculum
Development Skills and Knowledge |
|
20% (18) |
43% (39) |
37% (33) |
2.17 |
Student
Achievement Assessment Skills and Knowledge |
|
23% (21) |
40% (36) |
37% (33) |
2.13 |
Human
Relations Skills and Knowledge |
|
3% (3) |
18% (16) |
78% (69) |
2.75 |
Fiscal
Management Skills and Knowledge |
|
12% (11) |
29% (26) |
59% (54) |
2.47 |
Technology
Skills and Knowledge |
|
50% (44) |
39% (34) |
11% (10) |
1.61 |
Community
Relations Skills and Knowledge |
|
10% (9) |
22% (20) |
68% (62) |
2.58 |
Facilities
Management Skills and Knowledge |
|
35% (31) |
42% (37) |
24% (21) |
1.89 |
Total Respondents |
90 |
Comments
- work well with administrators and teachers in addition to community. recognize and address problems with key personnel. ability to recognize areas in which he or she is not strong and to hire trustworthy personnel to create balance.
- I would like to see someone who has a long term commitment to our community.
- Unquestioned integrity and commitment to achievement for all students. Retain our best and embrace all to make sure that we lose no one student
- real "meat"--no fluff; cheerleading squad isn't always right
- I want to have a Superintendant who is from AUSD, and not a temporary transplant who plans to stay for a short while and who takes a year or more to get to know the schools and teachers. I have worked with superintendants since 1965 and the best ones were from our district. It is crucial that the superintendant knows Alameda. Nishino didn't even know that Alameda was an island for six months!
- 1. Leadership 2. Strategic planning 3. Effective in making organizational change 4. Knows how to drive to results
- I think that one of the great things about Chacones is that he had a vision for excellence. He wasn't great at the administration side but her had a bold vision. Nishino seemed to have strength in finance but not much else.... Ideally the new Superintendent would be able to create a great bond with teachers and parents. Also, I want him/her to focus not only on the improving education for the lower performing students but ensuring that we continue to provide excellent education for the high performing children. I will say that Alameda HIgh does a great job of having "tracks" for high achieving kids but it doesn't seem that the middle schools do. Also, it seemed that as a district we were really onto something when we created magnet schools that pulled from across the island. I'm not suer why we have abandoned Bravo program, The Wood Academy etc. Thanks for asking for my input
- Leadership skills in the sense of being able to inspire and coach others to perform their best; knowledge of and experience with principled negotiation; personal time management skills; interpersonal skills, including ability to have "Difficult Conversations" (another book in the Harvard Negotiation Project series)
- Familiarity with the Alameda community
- Committment to arts education and the drive to make it happen. Committment to expanding GATE program so that high-achieving children can thrive instead of being bored as they are now.
- Communication skills with youths and teens. Mediation skills for issues with parents/teens for school personal issues.
- We are all also looking for a School District that reflects an integrated approach to education. So much of our past has been teachers vs. Superintendent vs.district office vs. parents. Are there no templates or models out there to help guide us to this next level?
- Must spend time walking the campus on a daily basis
- Someone who can be looked up to and be a leader in education who will lead our school district into providing an excellant education for the children of all incomes and cultures who live here. Not a good 'ole person or a person of a certain race or culture, but selected because they are the best.
- Basic pedagogy! How kids work and learn. Critical thinking. Creativity in problem solving.
- Community involvement and an attachement to the community. Must live in the community.
- The affinity and connection with children/students and their needs, including students with disability. Placing student improvements and enhancements top of priority when considering budgets. Should understand that their position is to serve the students in preparing them to meet the challenges and grooming them to be future leaders of the community/country.
- Ability to judge skill and talent in the hiring of principals. Ability to converse with parents one on one.
- We do not have thecapacity to spread ourselves so thin. We need to narrow our focus, define the leverage actions and stay the course.
- Technology skills are not a big deal to me - that can be delegated. But it would be good if they can figure out how to use email.
- Direction and focus of the community and district - the immediate and future goals. Long term committment and dedication.
- Ability to speak with parents and community and to be openly and honestly available to parents. I have not seen this in the past... Being shuffled around the district office is not acceptable
- I would like to see a superintendent who is committed to raising achievement for all students in Alameda. In particular, I would appreciate a superintendent who understands how to raise achievement for immigrant kids, English Learners and kids at the bottom of the heap and HAS HAD EXPERIENCE DOING SO.
- Wide curious, open mindedness toward multiple methods of meeting students needs. Willingness to allow more than one perpective to be heard. Respect and acknowledge success of all employees. Not just those that promote a certain program.
- 1. Openness to innovation, ability to work with active community resources and groups from all backgrounds and community sectors. 2. Ability to be accessible to and open to public and news inquiries, enter into community dialogues and discussions of community issues affecting education. 3. Ability to work harmoniously with unions, staff, teachers at all levels. We need open communication, cooperation, and transparency.
- Specifically, a "customer relations" approach to running the District. I feel that the culture at the District, which has been long held, not just with our last superintendent, as been one of the staff "doing us a favor by being there". Rather, I would suggest that the attitude be that we are their "customers" and their goal is to work toward our goals and state, federal standards. Too often we are told "to butt out" and "don't give out my number". I find that unacceptable ~ none of us are above the checks and balances that should be in place.
- A strong background in special education
- I would like to have someone who works well with others, communicates well and wants to stay in Alameda a long time. I hate seeing waste in our school system. We need someone who is fiscally savvy and has a long-term vision for facilities and labor relations.
- The Superintendent MUST have personal knowledge of AUSD and it's functions, someone who has been working in AUSD for years.
- Someone who visits campuses and gets to know and appreciate her/his employees.
- I would hope that her philsophy of education extends beyond the classrooms and school buildings into the community and that she sees the potential for the district to make a postive impact on parents as well as children.
- Knowledge of the local community and experience dealing with the variety of stake holders.
- The Superintendent is the highest ranking, most visible member of our school community. With that in mind I believe the new Superintendent should have a management level understanding of all of the specific areas listed above, but must have a knowledge of the community, schools, current personnel, and major problems facing this district. It doesn't make sense to me to look outside AUSD because it would take an outsider many months just to get up to functioning speed and we don't have the luxury of having that much time. We have decisions that should be made now.
- I feel that the Superintendent should be an individual who has been an active member of the Alameda learning community.... An individual who has lived in Alameda, raised children in Alameda schools and has been actively involved with the school as a teacher and a principal. We do NOT want a commuting Sup who doesn't grasp the essence of the community. Bay Farm 1st grade teacher
- Ability to relate to all community groups and bring them together to support the children of Alameda.
- Hey Mike, I will be coming to a few of the meetings and want to share some of my feelings as an employee, past union president, parent, and Equal Opportunity Committee member and some of my insights in sitting on the districts hiring panels for the past 12 years.
- INTEGRITY, HONESTY, AND A LACK OF POLITICAL AGENDA
- Diversity. Lack of arrogance. Time for each child and teacher.
- I think the next superintendant should be a uniter who really involves others in the decision making process. Prioritizing our scarce resources should also be important, since it is very clear that the budget will be inadequate to the needs of AUSD. I also have a strong preference for a superintendant who lives in the community. I think it makes a real difference if senior management is connected to Alameda in daily life.
- I would like to have a super who is progressive thinking. There is too much emphasis on test scores and technology is not the answer. I don't want my kids sitting in front of a computer, instead of instructed by a caring teacher. I think the physical atmosphere can have a great impact on students desire to be at school, and the middle schools and high schools look terrible. There needs to be a caring maintenance dept, who have the kids (not easy maintenance) as a priority.
- Motivational, charismatic and able to connect with the community. High expectations for staff and student achievement. Ability to bring people together and unify them around common goals. Good follow through on legal issues and compliance issues as well as ethical.
- I would like to see someone who has a demonstrated ability to work well with our teaching professionals.
- I would like to see skills in developing programs for marginalized children. For instance, he or she should be able to recognize and develop locally a program to teach ADHD children to read. At risk children need special attention, and this should be a priority.
- A vision for education.
- Understanding of special education in terms of the District's duty to provide every student with the tools to succeed & be independent. This is a fundamental right. Too often special ed has been a scapegoat for financial problems -- because people who often lack the time & savvy to self-advocate aren't likely to protest.
- I think that experience and expertise working with a diverse community of families and students is most important. Next the ability to inspire and make the best use of teachers and administrators in the District.
- L E A D E R S H I P AND COMMUNICATION, NOT ONLY WITH THE DISTRICT, BUT WITH THE KIDS, PARENTS, AND COMMUNITY G U T S TO GET RID OF THE CRUMMY PEOPLE!
- I spread out the top ones figuring we can't have must haves on everything. The most important to me is someone who is trying to reach out to the comunity and talk to parents and the community. If they have the right management skills they can hire the right people for the positions such as technology. Someone who gets real equity. I am saddened at what is offered to chipman compared to Wood and Lincoln. The truth is the equity there is in better management and staff than the other 2 schools.
- Ideally our next superintendent would not only be graced with good academic and fiscal knowledge BUT would be able to personally implement forward thinking ideas. The superintendent should be able to unite city officials, school board, teacher union, parents and students to achieve a STATED common goal (other than higher test scores). Yes, students need to be able to recognize who the superintendent is!
- an appreciation and awareness of equity an ability to develop relationships with administrators and teachers participation in the community approachability
- Knowledge of the Alameda community
Experience
|
|
Important |
Very
Important |
Must Have |
Response
Average |
Teacher |
|
18% (14) |
31% (25) |
51% (41) |
2.34 |
Principal |
|
23% (18) |
37% (29) |
41% (32) |
2.18 |
District
Fiscal Position |
|
49% (36) |
36% (26) |
15% (11) |
1.66 |
District
Personnel Position |
|
61% (44) |
25% (18) |
14% (10) |
1.53 |
District
Curriculum Position |
|
48% (36) |
43% (32) |
9% (7) |
1.61 |
District
Technology Position |
|
81% (55) |
18% (12) |
1% (1) |
1.21 |
District
Assessment Position |
|
66% (48) |
29% (21) |
5% (4) |
1.40 |
District
Special Education Position |
|
77% (51) |
23% (15) |
0% (0) |
1.23 |
Total Respondents |
82 |
Comments
- worked at sites that serve students from low SES, title 1, etc. It is not possible to truly understand the challenges faced if you have only head about them... must be lived.
- The district needs a fresh face and new perspective. Where it's going now started a few years ago and can be carried forward by a competent experienced person.
- If the candidate has been in a classroom for a significant amount of time, She or he will have a better understanding of current education. The person should not have the majority of his/her experience in private schools.
- I do not believe the candidate must have followed any single career path. Many distriicts have moved business leaders into the superintendent role--some with good results and some without those results. Similarly, many who have experience in education have succeeded while others have not. Helpful experiences would include: - successful leadership in an environment with a wide variety of stakeholders who want different things - experience with different functions is helpful because a leader need not be expert in everything but they need to know how to utilize and respect all the different functions--this is easier if they have experience in both line/staff roles and or in multiple areas (principal, district, etc) - experience fixing something that is broken - experience implementing a change successfully - experience starting something from scratch
- I am concerned and frightened by the selections to choose from under "Experience" for Alameda's Superintendent of Schools. Howabout educational leadership? School redesign? Community involvment? All must haves...
- Affiliation with local community groups
- Experience working with the Board of Education and other elected officials (someone with Distict-level experience who has "staffed" the Board - not the less regular interaction typical of principals). Which position is less important than the direct interaction and, therefore, understanding of how a board works.
- I don't see particular experience as being as important as the type of person they are and what their actual skills are.
- With a great team the superintendent needs to know when to be a leader and when to follow. One person can learn if surrouned by a strong team.
- Private sector management of resources and personnel, demonstrated sense of vision!
- The best would have experience "in the trenches" as a teacher and perhaps principal, and have some knowledge of the other positions, as well as a variety of jobs which exposed him/her to how the world works in a non-education setting.
- I presume candidates are being promoted up from within the Alameda district. i don't know whether or not that is necessary - bringing in a very qualified person from outside the district might cause resentment and difficulties; but limiting ourselves to someone from within the Alameda district may not work if we don't have anyone with across-the-board qualifications
- Very active in their local community and knowledge of the different groups and trends that their city has/are going through. Being active during good and hardship struggles that a city experience. Positive relationship/experience with all levels of their departments and the district.
- Direct experience in some of the above areas is less important than a full understanding of and support for thosae working in technology, special ed, facilities, etc. Union leadership experience might help generate credibility with teacher 's unions...
- Obviously, strong managements skills. I think of the superintendent as being the CEO of the "Corporation". They need not have each individual skill within the district, but have a good overall understanding of all the areas he/she manages. He/she must build a strong base of lower management to upper management and allow those with expertise in their field to do their job, until proven otherwise.
- Business experience would be an asset
- Proven track record of staying in budget and getting the job done.
- This can only be done by someone who has been working in the district for year like Ardella Dailey.
- Must be a people person!
- I would hope that she would have the understanding that not all children and families are created equal and that some children require addtional services to reach their learning potential. i am not referring to Special Ed. I am referring to the many children who are "punished" by the educational systems failure to meet their needs because of funding and lack of vision and leadership. These are often children born into poverty, violence and non priveledged ethnic groups.
- Experience with local community
- All of the positions listed seem too specific. We need someone with a broad background of district experience and knowledge, not necessarily in one specific area. You left off Assiatant Superintendent.
- Needs to have had a variety of principal positions and other district position to have a broad view of the school district.
- Leadership
- I have an overwhelming bias that a superintendant should have at least some experience at the high school level. If he/she has never worked in a high school, I do not believe a successful superintendancy is possible. The most complicated issues of curriculum, credits, graduation requirements, UC approval, extra curricular activities, standardized testing all come in high school.
- Experienced at working with staff.
- They need to have come up through the ranks and have experience in ANY cabinet level position. They need to be able to relate to both elementary and secondary issues - without bias. Both levels of programs have very diverse needs which sometimes don't relate to each other. Training in Organizational Developement / Leadership (Masters and or Doctorate) - preferably doctorate in Educational Leadership.
- Community outreach is very important as a background skill.
- Non-education experience. Superintendent has to have perspective that extends beyond the ivy tower. A large part of the job is community relations.
- Experience with Labor Relations and alternative and small school development would be good.
- I'm interpreting "fiscal position" and "personnel position" loosely, not necessarily meaning head of those specific departments, but a position that oversees substantial district personnel and finances. For example, prior experience as a superintendent would cover that "must have" requirement.
- What else is there?
Personal Traits
|
|
Important |
Very
Important |
Must Have |
Response
Average |
Trustworthiness:
To act in a manner that makes one worthy of trust and confidence |
|
2% (2) |
14% (12) |
83% (69) |
2.81 |
Truthtfulness:
To act with personal responsibility and mental accountability |
|
2% (2) |
13% (11) |
84% (70) |
2.82 |
Active
Listening: To listen attentively and the intention of understanding |
|
2% (2) |
29% (24) |
68% (56) |
2.66 |
No
Put-Downs: To never use words, actions, and/or body language that degrade,
humiliate or dishonor others |
|
5% (4) |
27% (22) |
69% (57) |
2.64 |
Personal
Best: To do one's best given the circumstance and available resources |
|
6% (5) |
30% (24) |
64% (51) |
2.58 |
Caring:
To feel and show concern for others |
|
9% (7) |
41% (33) |
51% (41) |
2.42 |
Common
Sense: To use good judgment |
|
6% (5) |
12% (10) |
82% (67) |
2.76 |
Cooperation:
To work together toward a common goal or purpose |
|
4% (3) |
16% (13) |
80% (64) |
2.76 |
Courage:
To act according to one's belief |
|
15% (12) |
27% (22) |
58% (47) |
2.43 |
Curiousity:
A desire to investigate and seek understanding of one's world |
|
23% (18) |
31% (24) |
46% (36) |
2.23 |
Effort:
To do your best |
|
10% (8) |
26% (21) |
64% (52) |
2.54 |
Flexibility:
To be willing to alter plans when necessary |
|
10% (8) |
23% (19) |
67% (55) |
2.57 |
Friendship:
To make and keep a friend through mutual trust and caring |
|
42% (32) |
29% (22) |
29% (22) |
1.87 |
Initiative:
To do something because it needs to be done |
|
6% (5) |
30% (24) |
64% (52) |
2.58 |
Integrity:
To act according to sense of what is right and wrong |
|
4% (3) |
18% (14) |
79% (63) |
2.75 |
Organization:
To plan, arrange and implement in an orderly way |
|
9% (7) |
27% (21) |
65% (51) |
2.56 |
Patience:
To wait calmly for someone or something |
|
28% (21) |
36% (27) |
37% (28) |
2.09 |
Perservance:
To keep at it |
|
13% (10) |
29% (23) |
58% (45) |
2.45 |
Problem-Solving:
To create solutions for difficult situations and problems |
|
4% (3) |
22% (18) |
74% (61) |
2.71 |
Responsibility:
To respond when appropriate, to be accountable for your actions |
|
4% (3) |
9% (7) |
87% (69) |
2.84 |
Sense
of Humor: To laugh and be playful without harming others |
|
29% (22) |
23% (18) |
48% (37) |
2.19 |
Total Respondents |
83 |
Comments
- Be truly thoughtful, reflective and forward thinking in your decision.
- Alameda's schools need a unifying leader who has a strong public presence and the ability to lead. He/she must be able to articulate goals in a meaningful way and be committed to complete accountability.
- I am pleased with the performance now (and the last time she was acting superintendent) with Ardella Dailey. I would recommend that we save further money and name Ms. Dailey superintendent.
- The candidate should be a person who works in AUSD or has worked in AUSD, such as Ardella Dailey, John Sugiyama, or Keith Namura. It is a waste of time and money to "recruit" someone who doesn't know or care about Alameda.
- I think Ardella is a perfect candidate to be our superintendent. She has been in the district for a number of years and has held varied positions, lives in the community and has had children go through the school system. Because of these factors, she is able to understand concerns brought to her attention. She is friendly, caring, understanding, available to meet regarding any concerns one may have, and understands the history and politics of Alameda that make this city and district unique.
- Jack Welch suggests 4 key criteria: Energizes others Has personal energy Makes the tough decisions Executes I think they fit well. I think someone who respects and values our teachers and will work collaboratively with them is very important. I have heard the teachers praise Ardella Dailey and hope she is under serious consideration. We must solve our technology problems. I have chaired SSC for over 3 years and it is consistently the #1 barrier our teachers mention. I personally spent 100+ hours last year fixing computer things. We have parents with expertise that can help -- let's use them! I do not think the leader needs to know the technology answers -- but she should know how to engage the right people to get to the answers. I also think the leader needs to set standards and hold district staff accountable. While some are wonderful, others are simply incompetent. We have too few $'s to tolerate this. So we need someone who sets high standards, holds people accountable, and makes the hard calls about people. Thanks for doing the survey!
- Other qualities: - Strong leadership skills - Strong communications skills - Innovative ideas, especially when it comes to saving the school district money or raising money for the school district. * Please do a thorough job in getting a background check on candidates. If possible, talk to other references not given by the candidate.
- It will be very interesting the results of this survey. Frankly, I think it is fairly predictive. Not much different thinking. If we go with the old California model .. CTA/Administrators/Superintendents/CSBA odds are we will get the same crappy schools, with bright lights somewhere. I suggest different thinking and planning! Guess who!
- Collaborative attitude
- I believe a superindent should be able to tap the power and ability of Community Based Organizations to service the students needs without putting undue stress on the district budget.
- I plan to attend the meeting on 9/29.
- I have worked with Ardella in BRAG and APCAC and find her to be open, objective, thoughtful, problem solving, caring,intelligent and incorporating many of the attributes noted in your survey.
- I would like to see a strong leader who isn't overly focused on test scores, but instead will do the most possible to support each child to fluorish, and make the schools as equitable as possible. Some of the things this means are GATE or other programs that are appropriate for the highest-achieving students (whose needs are currently very poorly met); appropriate help for the lower-achieving students; a broad arts education - visual arts, music, dance, drama, taught by professional artist/teachers - for every child, every day.
- I own my own child care and have children past and currently in the school system. I have sat on boards for Alameda and feel that many officials affiliated with education lack knowledge in spacific areas of the field. This is a problem that needs to be addressed with the next superintendent.
- We need a new superintendent who is not from this area! We need new ideas and a person who is not part of the current bureaucracy.
- please see first page input.
- see previous comments
- The people reviewing the applicants should look for demonstrated use of good judgement. Denis "cared" but his judgement in managing the fiscal affairs of the district was faulty. Our community deserves a person who is caring and, at the same time practical and has the skills to sort things out so that which has to be done is done. Also communications is critical. Our last super was unable/unwilling to be available and keep in touch with all elements of the community. Visibility and openness is what keeps the community supportive of the schools.
- Considerable classroom experience is absolutely essential for any superintendent. That is to say, extended, frequent, regular, one on one contact with students as well as experience in a classroom setting is absolutely essential for anyone at an administrative level in education.
- It is crucial to me that our superintendent be highly supportive of more than a 3-Rs curriculum. That means plenty of PE, music, art, and science.
- Would like someone whose goal is in line with the district - to help it grow but understand the hardships it's going through. To stand by and give a helping hand when needed - down to the lowest level if need be.
- I am concerned that a narrow focus without willingness to listen to others has become the way district office deals with employees. Teachers have been targeted when they challenged misleading information. Knowlegeable, expert, respected teachers have been put down in district meetings if they asked questions. Certain schools seem to be the only ones who are "doing it right". Example: How many people in the district know that Longfellow school has a reading clinic that teachers graduate students students to become reading specialists? These graduate students, who are already experienced teachers, tutor Longfellow students in their St. Mary's class at Longfellow. I am willing to bet that not a cingle district office person has ever visited this program. We have a program in our district that is traingin teachers form elsewhere to earn a reading specialist credential but our district doesn't want to learn about it. Longfellow School showed 80 points growth and I am willing to bet they are closing the acheivement gap at this school. However, has anyone visited that school to congratulate or find out about their programs? This is just one example of the "closed" mentality teachers in this district are struggling to understand of distict leadership. AUSD has some fantastic teachers and I believe a superintendent needs to honor it own employees and support teachers' growth without creating fear or put downs. The saying "a trainer becomes a consultant when he goes 10 miles away. We need to "look in our own backyard" for talent. A huge amount of money has been spent on staff development that was less than effective or supportive.
- The above list sounds like the one we're trying to teach our students at Franklin Elementary, where I volunteer. :-) Many are required in any position (integrity, honesty, communication), from volunteer to janitor to 5th grade student to principal... Alameda students and teachers need an ope, compasssionate advocate who can manage other "experts" in facilities (Bob DeLuca) or technology w/out being an expert herself. S/he need not be "familiar" with Alameda, but must fit Alameda's cross-communities "involvement by al in all." Accessibility to the public, staff, unions, PTA, community, and to press is critical,plus transparency in her/his methods and decision-making style. Openness to new ideas and strategies, ability to find/be financial wizards and tech experts a plus, but not needed in the Superintendent herself. Thanks for this! (Noon recess, Walk & Roll to School, Safe Routes to School Pilot Project)
- Thank you very much for making this survey available to the general public. I think all our input is extremely valuable. To close, I would also like to suggest that the position have yearly reviews, at open to the public school board meeting, PRIOR to the superintendent's contract being renewed. I think this is as important as seeking it during the search. Timely notices about such review meetings must be made, so all who wish to speak in favor or against, have an opportunity. We asked the community to fund our schools to benefit the city at large, we need to allow everyone an opportunity to participate in this important decision.
- I would like to see a Superintendent who is accessible to District employees and is supportive of teachers. A Superintendent who has respect for the people who work in the trenches is a must have.
- I would like the new Superintendent to develop a strong relationship with the community. I feel that if we can create a "We're in this together" attitude we will be much better off. I have been very disappointed with the current technology position of the district. I felt they were trying to run before they could walk. Examples: last year, Bay Farm, Edison and Earhart PTAs were all trying help purchase computers for their schools. They were all stonewalled by the district. The district policy was all new computers donated to the district must be the same as those purchased by the last bond measure. As a result, a lot of time and money was wasted and fewer computers were replaced. The district also has the admin ids locked down so much that parents can not help their local schools. Everything has to go through the district which is extremely undermanned.
- Keep Ardella Dailey as Superintendent - PLEASE!
- Keep Ardella. She is off to a great start. She wants the position for all of the right reasons - to help children learn and achieve their best. She is accessible and embodies all of the characteristics on the previous section. I don't think that she is doing this for personal glory. She has stuck it out here through tough times and deserves a shot at the job. I think that the fact that so many retired employees have come back to help, speaks volumes about their loyalty to Ardella and her ability to do the job.
- See my first page comment. I also believe that it is wasteful for our District to employ a company to find a Superintendent when the best candidate is looking right at you!
- Able to evaluate things when something is not working and move in another direction -- open to other ideas and seeks new input to find the solution.
32. ARDELLA HAS BEEN DOING A FANTASTIC JOB. SHE IS A GEM. THANKS FOR WASTING $7800.
- Hire Ardella
- Thanks for doing this Mike. Good luck in your selection process. I appreciate all the hours you put in as a board member.
- The last page was silly. Of course you want all those things
- This survey was a great idea on how to get input from the community. Rely on the California School Boards Association Search process - they do a really good job helping to define what the community wants. Be sure the new superintendent gets training from the California School Boards association and from ACSA. Thanks!
- It is disgraceful that the district is willing to spend up to 13K to a consulting board when there is a willing and able applicant who is acting as the current superintendant. I am sure the special ed department could put the 13K to good use instead.
- A panel (similar to School Site Council but on a broader scale) with members representing the Board, teachers, staff, principals, district employees, community members, parents (elem., middle, high, gate, special ed, non-english speaking)with an equal number of parents vs. everyone else should interview and vote to elect our next superintendent, including pay, and the process should be transparent.
- I want a open minded superintendent, who can think outside of the box.
- I think the superintendent as a minimum needs to be a competent
administrator who understands the current issues in education. Very importantly the superintendent needs to be responsive to the community ---students, parents, teachers and taxpayers. Ideally the superintendent would be a creative problem solver who has the long term interest of the community in mind.
- I've emphasized personal relations and communication abilities as paramount for two reasons: (1) the superintendent serves as interface with the community and must be able to communicate well, and (2) because this was a weak point for Dr. Nishino and it left many in our district feeling demoralized. Sadly, Dr. Nishino's resignation elicited cheers---literal floor-jumping whoops of joy---from all the teachers I know. They had felt very personally disregarded and disrespected by him. All the parents I talked to felt the same way. Particularly in times of tight budget, the ability to raise morale will be a key attribute of a DS.
- I will tell you that I have more confidence in what is going on right now than anytime since we have been here. I see pleasant changes in the district office from the moment you walk in. I hear about meetings to revisit spending on school repairs (the lifeskill of open mindedness) and good people have been willing to come to the aid of the district because they obviously have faith in the direction it is going. I am not saying don't look. I am saying don't shut your eyes to what you see going on right now. It is happening quietly as Ardela is not a flag waiver, but good things are happening. The district has some mean movers and shakers making things happen right now and I am happy as can be.
- important that we overcome the closed quality of the administration it is important that as we continue to face more and more financial problems that employees feel that they are part of the team and respected.
- Mike: Thanks..I'll send this out to my PTA list.
TOP
Comments. Questions. Broken links? Bad spelling! Incorrect Grammar? Let me know at webmaster.
Last modified: October 14, 2005
Disclaimer: This website is the sole responsibility of Mike
McMahon. It does not represent any official opinions, statement of facts or
positions of the Alameda Unified School District. Its sole purpose is to
disseminate information to interested individuals in the Alameda community.
|